I. Human Rights, Legal Reform and War Crimes
Despite gradual improvements such as greater freedom of movement, fewer
arbitrary arrests, and a more responsible attitude on the part of the
authorities, the Council deplores the fact that the protection of human
rights in Bosnia and Herzegovina is still inadequate. The Council
reiterates that the extensive list of human rights obligations, which
form part of the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina and the Peace
Agreement, must be respected and that current laws must be reviewed to
determine their compatibility with international standards of human
rights. Few steps have been taken to ensure that the direct application
of the rights and freedoms set forth in the European Convention on Human
Rights is effectively implemented in Bosnia and Herzegovina and
underlying structural problems have yet to be addressed. Until those
problems are resolved, human rights violations threaten to remain
endemic.
The Council takes note of the High Representative's recent report to
the Council of Europe on the situation of human rights in Bosnia and
Herzegovina. The High Representative will regularly report to the
Steering Board on progress in this field in connection with the
application of Bosnia and Herzegovina for membership in the Council of
Europe.
- Human Rights Issues
- The Council is deeply concerned that the Federation and Republika
Srpska have not amended their property and housing legislation to make
full implementation of Annex 7 of the Peace Agreement possible. These
laws continue to block the return of hundreds of thousands of refugees
and displaced persons to their pre-war homes. This situation will not be
condoned. Changes to the laws of both Entities must be adopted
immediately. The Federation will be held to its commitment, made at the
Federation Forum on 12 November 1997, to adopt the three draft laws
submitted by the High Representative, or otherwise the High
Representative will recommend appropriate measures to the Steering
Board. Republika Srpska is urgently asked to amend its property and
housing legislation within 60 days of the new Government taking office.
Non-compliance measures will be applied according to the recommendations
of the High Representative.
- The Council expects the authorities in Bosnia and Herzegovina to
co-operate fully with the Commission on Human Rights and the Commission
for Real Property Claims (CRPC). In particular, the authorities of both
Entities must ensure that the decisions of the Human Rights Chamber and
the CRPC are respected, and must respond appropriately to reports of the
Ombudsperson. To that end, Bosnia and Herzegovina and the Entities
should adopt legislation for the CRPC, in accordance with the draft
proposed by the High Representative, as soon as possible.
- It is essential that the Commission on Human Rights and the CRPC
receive adequate and stable funding to carry out the tasks envisaged by
the Peace Agreement. The Presidency of Bosnia and Herzegovina has
recognised this obligation, and made a nominal contribution to each
institution from the 1997 budget of Bosnia and Herzegovina. The
authorities must commit themselves to incremental increases in funding,
with a view to assuming full responsibility as soon as possible and at
the very latest at the end of the five-year transition period. In the
interim, the Council remains committed to ensuring that funding
constraints do not impede the work of the Commissions. To that end, the
Council commits itself to addressing any funding gaps.
- The Council emphasises that education must promote understanding and
reconciliation among the ethnic, religious and cultural groups in Bosnia
and Herzegovina, while recognising the right of parents to choose the
nature of the education that their children receive. The Council notes
with concern that educational policy and programmes in the Federation
and Republika Srpska do not comply with these basic principles. The
Council urges the competent authorities to work together to ensure that
all persons are educated according to their needs and in a manner which
also contributes to tolerance and stability within a multi-ethnic Bosnia
and Herzegovina, and to develop without delay an education programme
consistent with these principles, in co-operation with the High
Representative, UNESCO, the Council of Europe, the European Commission,
the OSCE, UNICEF, the World Bank and other relevant organisations.
- The Council recognises that non-governmental organisations are vital
to pluralism and democracy and it supports the strengthening of civil
society as a whole. It notes that the current legislative framework in
Bosnia and Herzegovina hinders these objectives and urges the competent
authorities to establish a proper legal environment for civil society
organisations. It calls upon the OSCE to continue its human rights and
democratisation programmes.
- The Council calls upon the authorities in Bosnia and Herzegovina to
collaborate closely with national and international organisations
monitoring the human rights situation in Bosnia and Herzegovina. The
Council emphasises the need for these organisations to co-ordinate their
efforts through the Human Rights Co-ordination Centre Steering Board.
- Legal Reform
- The Council recognises that an impartial and independent judiciary is
essential to the rule of law and reconciliation within Bosnia and
Herzegovina. The judicial appointment process must be reformed to ensure
that selection is based on merit rather than political or ethnic
criteria, and a facility for judicial training must be established. The
Council stresses that monitoring of the judicial system is an essential
element of this process, and calls for the necessary resources to be
devoted to that task.
- The Council supports the ongoing criminal justice reform effort
within the Federation, and calls on the authorities, as a first step, to
implement the recommendations of the expert team regarding the criminal
procedure code by 31 January 1998.
The Council welcomes the request by Republika Srpska to the Council of
Europe to assist in the harmonisation of its criminal and criminal
procedure codes with European standards. The Council underlines,
however, that the expert teams set up by Republika Srpska for this
purpose should include representatives not only of the Council of
Europe, but also of the High Representative, UNMIBH and other relevant
institutions.
- The Council states that consistency and co-operation between the two
Entities in the area of legal reform is essential. To that end, it calls
for the establishment of a Commission for Inter-Entity Judicial
Co-operation, in accordance with the recommendation made by the High
Representative, to be operational no later than 31 January 1998. It also
notes the need to harmonise Federation and cantonal laws, and calls for
co-operation by the cantons. The Council endorses the High
Representative's co-ordination of the various judicial and legal reform
programmes within a coherent and focused programme including the
harmonisation of the criminal codes and criminal procedures of both
Entities with the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina and undertakes
to provide further assistance to the organisations involved in the
fulfilment of this mission. The Council welcomes the High
Representative's invitation to the Council of Europe, the OSCE and
UNMIBH to cooperate in a programme of judicial and legal reform.
Specifically, the Council welcomes the High Representative's request to
the UN, in accordance with Annex 11 of the Peace Agreement, to set up a
Task Force within UNMIBH to focus on the assessment and monitoring of
the court system, the development and training of legal professionals
and the restructuring of institutions within the judicial system, and
invites the UN to consider allocating any necessary resources.
- Missing Persons and Exhumations
The Council welcomes the efforts of the various international agencies,
including the ICRC, the High Representative, the ICMP and the
International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY), to
resolve the issue of persons unaccounted for, but expresses
dissatisfaction with the authorities in Bosnia and Herzegovina for not
meeting their responsibilities. It demands specifically that the
authorities:
- provide immediate and full information or assistance upon the request
of the international agencies to assist with the tracing process;
- ensure that the agreement to allow one another immediate access to
potential burial and mass grave sites for the process of exhumation and
retrieval of remains is implemented in full;
- cease immediately body-for-body exchanges and participate in the
exhumation process introduced by the High Representative.
- Reconciliation, War Crimes and Co-operation with the International
Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY)
- The Council is convinced that until all persons indicted for war
crimes are brought before the ICTY, there will be no normalisation, no
reconciliation, and the rule of law in Bosnia and Herzegovina will
remain seriously impaired. In this regard, the Council recalls the
Sintra Declaration, where the continued influence of Radovan Karadzic
over the political life of Republika Srpska was deemed unacceptable. The
Council therefore reminds all competent authorities that war crimes
suspects must be brought before the ICTY and that cooperation with ICTY
is a key part of the process of peace implementation. The Council
remains committed to applying economic levers and other measures to
ensure full co-operation with ICTY, including making recommendations to
Council members with regard to the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia. The
Council welcomes the transfers of war crimes indictees to the ICTY in
the course of 1997. The Council recalls Security Council resolution
1034. The Council demands that the competent authorities take immediate
steps to execute arrest warrants for all indicted persons under their
jurisdiction and to surrender them to the ICTY. This demand is made with
particular reference to Republika Srpska and the Federal Republic of
Yugoslavia. The Council recalls that domestic law prohibiting the
surrender of indictees to the ICTY is incompatible with mandatory United
Nations Security Council resolutions adopted under Chapter VII of the
Charter of the United Nations and Article IX of the General Framework
Agreement for Peace in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
- The Council notes the importance of compliance with the Rules of the
Road agreed at Rome in February 1996. It criticises local authorities in
both Entities who continue to refer to "lists of war crimes suspects" in
an attempt to discourage return of refugees and displaced persons,
harass citizens and deter elected municipal councillors from taking
office. The authorities must ensure that this ceases immediately. The
Council notes that municipalities that persist in this risk being named
as obstructionist by the High Representative and consequently risk
losing international assistance. Furthermore, the Council calls for
adequate resources to be made available to the Prosecutor of the ICTY
for the Rules of the Road.
- The Council requests that the High Representative, the ICTY and other
relevant organisations identify those persons who are aiding and
abetting individuals named in the arrest warrants and calls on member
States to take immediate measures against such persons, as may be
recommended by the High Representative.
|