|
24 FEBRUARY 2001 – 11 JUNE 2001
Pursuant to Security Council Resolution 1031 of 15 December 1995, which
requested the Secretary General to submit reports from the High Representative
in accordance with Annex 10 of the Peace Agreement and the Conclusions of the
London Peace Implementation Conference of 8-9 December 1995, I herewith present
the nineteenth report to the Council.
The Report covers the activities of the Office of the High Representative and
developments in Bosnia and Herzegovina during the period from 24 February 2001
until 11 June 2001.
SUMMARY
In the reporting period, my priority has been to accelerate peace
implementation in the three key strategic areas identified by the Peace
Implementation Council (PIC) in May 2000: economic reform, refugee return and
the consolidation of the State institutions. Special attention has been directed
at tackling the Croat nationalist challenge to the constitutional order and to
the worrying situation in RS, as well as at the implementation of the crucial
decision of the BiH Constitutional Court commonly known as the "Constituent
Peoples Case".
- The new non-nationalistic authorities at the State and Federation level,
as well as the IC, faced serious challenges from the forces that dominated BiH
life in the last 10 years:
- On 3 March, the HDZ –which had been ousted from power
by the "Alliance for Changes" after the November elections- proclaimed the
so-called "Croat Self-Rule". Four days later I decided to remove Mr. Jelavic
-Croat member of the BiH Presidency and HDZ President- from his positions, as
he personally led this serious violation of the constitutional order. On 6
April, I appointed a Provisional Administrator for the Hercegovacka Bank,
which acted as the financial backbone of the HDZ-led illegal parallel
structures. The new Federation authorities successfully thwarted the HDZ
efforts to disrupt the Federation Government, especially on financial and
military matters. I have made it clear to the HDZ that they can always return
to those institutions they had left, but that the IC will never compromise on
BiH’s constitutional principles.
- The Alliance-led Council of Ministers (CoM) faced constant obstruction
from Republika Srpska (RS) authorities. I have demanded the latter to change
their attitude; only in this way the RS’s viability will be guaranteed.
Moreover, the attempts in May to lay foundation stones of mosques in Banja
Luka and Trebinje –demolished by Serb extremists during the war- were
disrupted by serious Serb nationalistic violence. Following my demand to the
RS authorities to take swift measures conducing to reconciliation and reform
within the RS society, they publicly apologized for the violence, the RS
Interior Ministry’s leadership was replaced and a multi-ethnic Reform and
Reconciliation Committee was established under the auspices of the RS
President.
- On 5 March RS and FRY signed an agreement on Special
Parallel Relations (SPR), as provided for in the General Framework Agreement
for Peace (GFAP). I ensured that the agreement’s text and spirit fully respect
BiH’s sovereignty and territorial integrity. My Office has a supervisory role
in the agreement’s implementation and will be involved in the drafting of its
annexes
- The Communications Regulatory Agency (CRA) –merging
IMC and TRA- started to work in March. The CRA is a state-level regulator for
the media and the telecommunications sectors.
- The Independent Judicial Commission (IJC) - successor
to UNMIBH's JSAP and tasked with overseeing reform of the BiH judiciary – had
significantly increased its staffing by the end of April, including deployment
of its field teams.
- Following my Decision in February imposing binding
arbitration over the delineation of the Inter Entity Boundary Line (IEBL) in
Dobrinja (a Sarajevo suburb), the special Arbitrator issued his Award on 24
April. Its implementation has been carried out satisfactorily.
- On 7 May Radio PBS (Public Broadcasting Service)
started broadcasts for the whole of BiH. For the first time since the
disintegration of the former Yugoslavia, BiH has a statewide broadcasting
capability
- Following the BiH Constitutional Court’s decision on
the "Constituent Peoples Case", the process of constitutional reform
progressed steadily in both Entities. These constitutional changes will have a
decisive impact on the future outlook of BiH’s social and political life.
- Under my separate mandate for the succession of the Socialist Federal
Republic of Yugoslavia (SFRY), I mediated the final round of the negotiations
in Vienna, together with the Special Negotiator, Sir Arthur Watts. On 25 May,
the five successor states initialed an agreement that provided for the
distribution of its rights, obligations, assets and liabilities.
I. POLITICAL ISSUES
1. State Institutions
- On 27 March the BiH House of Representatives (HoR)
elected Beriz Belkic (SBiH) and Jozo Krizanovic (SDP) as the Bosniak and Croat
members of the BiH Presidency respectively. The House of Peoples (HoP)
confirmed this election on 30 March.
- Following its formation on 22 February, the new CoM,
under the chairmanship of Mr. Bozidar Matic, began working in an efficient
manner. The CoM adopted its Work Programme in March and has made some progress
in its implementation since. However, legislative activities and the
implementation process are regularly challenged and obstructed by RS
authorities, on the grounds that the CoM’s legislative agenda invades the RS
competencies. I have demanded the RS authorities to clarify their objections
constructively and cooperate with CoM, for the benefit of RS’s viability and
BiH’s normalization, especially in view of its participation in the European
integration processes.
- In order to ensure the effective functioning of the State institutions,
the new State authorities and my Office have started investigating various
other means of financing the State Budget, as it is currently almost entirely
dependent on contributions from the Entities. We expect to find independent
sources of income for the State in the nearby future, and will work to this
end in close cooperation with local authorities and international financial
institutions.
- Progress in the BiH Parliamentary Assembly, however,
has been less satisfactory. The Alliance, a fragile coalition with a very
tight majority of 22 out of 42 delegates in the HoR, is proving increasingly
difficult to hold together. The BiH Parliamentary Assembly has not passed any
new legislation of major importance to date. One positive development is that
the HDZ delegates in the HoR, after a boycott of State institutions that
lasted several months, are pursuing their goals from their elected seats once
again. They have been especially active during the debate over the BiH’s
Election Law.
2. The Entities and Brcko
a) Republika Srpska (RS)
- Since February, several positive developments have
occurred in the RS. Prime Minister Ivanic managed to stabilize the
social-economic situation, by increasing the efficiency of tax collection and,
to some degree, improving fiscal discipline. Important progress on
constitutional changes was made in April as the re-shaped Constitutional
Commission agreed on draft amendments to the RS Constitution.
- On the negative side, the effort to reconstruct
religious sites demolished during the last war was set back when mosque
cornerstone laying ceremonies in Trebinje and Banja Luka were disrupted in May
by violent protests (which resulted in one death and several injuries) and had
to be postponed. Following these events, my goal has been to ensure that the
RS handles the fallout from these crises in a robust and comprehensive manner.
I immediately demanded an investigation into the violence; immediate changes
of leadership in the Ministry of Interior; public condemnation and an apology
by top RS officials; repetition of the ceremonies and the establishment of a
multi-ethnic Reform and Reconciliation Committee under the auspices of the RS
President. Even though they have complied with most of these demands, I am
following closely the RS authorities’ performance on all these issues.
- The agreement on SPR between RS and the Federal
Republic of Yugoslavia (FRY) was signed on 5 March and ratified on 7 June.
Although the concept of "special" relations between an Entity and a
neighboring country is an outdated concept, such an agreement is a right of
the Entities, in conformity with the GFAP. The strong reference to the GFAP
and to the BiH Constitution in the preamble of the agreement is the basis for
subsequent annexes, which will elaborate the scope of the co-operation.
- Some Bosniac and Croat members of the RS
Constitutional Commission opposed the ratification of the agreement on SPR
claiming that it violated their vital national interest. In their opinion, an
agreement between BiH and FRY was required and not one between the RS and FRY,
which –they believed- violates the BiH Constitution. In my official response
to their claim, I stated that the contents of the agreement did not violate
their national interests and that it was in complete conformity with the BiH
Constitution.
- In the text of the agreement, my Office has been
guaranteed a supervisory/ monitoring role and will be involved in the drafting
of the annexes. However, I attach crucial importance to more intensive
state-to-state relations. Some of the problems which are important for the RS
and its residents can only be solved at the State level (citizenship, border
regime, etc) and not at the Entity level.
b) Federation
- Nearly four months after the November 2000 elections,
the Federation of BiH got its first non-nationalist government on 12 March. It
was formed by the "Alliance for Changes". However, this new Government was
challenged by the HDZ leadership and the so-called ‘Croat National Assembly
(HNS),’ which on 3 March voted to establish an unconstitutional ‘Croat
self-rule in BiH’. In late March HDZ radicals in Mostar moved to oust that
city's Mayor, Mr. Tomic (a moderate HDZ member). These attempts failed due to
a lack of the necessary votes in the Municipal Council. However, HDZ
hard-liners continue to pressure Mr. Tomic, who they see as an obstacle to the
establishment of a separate Croat entity. ‘HNS’ officials also instructed
Croats and their legally elected representatives to reject the newly elected
Federation Government. On 13 March, HDZ officials ordered the disbanding of
the Croat component of the Federation Army, followed on 28 March by a walkout
of Croat officers and soldiers from their barracks.
- The efforts of this illegal "Croat Self-Rule" to
control the Federation financial institutions (mainly, the customs offices) in
the Croat-majority areas has failed, thanks to the firm attitude of the
Federation government.
- On 16 May, Federation Defense Minister Anic and some
BiH Croat Generals brokered a tentative agreement which allowed Croat soldiers
one month to renew their contracts with the Defense Ministry and return to
their barracks. As the time period for this report expired, the official
agreement broke down, but a significant number of Croat soldiers --
particularly from Central Bosnia and from the northern region of Posavina --
had reportedly renewed their contracts.
c) Brcko
- I continue to be satisfied with developments in the
Brcko District (BD). One year after its establishment, progress continued in
particular in the areas of:
- Return: Both entities and the BD Government are
enacting a joint program for Displaced Persons’ (DPs) housing reconstruction
worth 6 million KM (1 KM = $ 0.5 approx.), which should result in 500 housing
resolutions in the current year. The BD continues to be in the top 5% of
municipalities in the Property Law Implementation Program (PLIP), with an
average of over 100 properties reinstated each month.
- Judicial system: A modern judicial system -consisting
of a basic court, an appellate court, a legal aid center and a judicial
commission- was established on 1 April and is functioning well under a set of
progressive District laws.
- Budget: A transparent budget was adopted in April and the District is
financially self-sustainable, a result of the District Government’s efforts to
collect all revenues to which it is entitled.
- Both Entities’ Governments have shown, in general, a
positive and supportive attitude towards the District, including efforts
towards an integrated educational system. The latter, however, is not yet
reflected by the attitude of local Serb political parties. Both Prime
Ministers have appointed permanent Liaison Officers to facilitate dialogue and
communication. I fully endorse the BD Supervisor’s current focus on
privatization, tax legislation and re-opening navigation on the Sava river.
3. Election Issues
- In view of the fact that the November 2000 elections
were the last for which the OSCE bore responsibility, the adoption of an
Election Law has become particularly pressing. The adoption of such a Law is
one of the main obligations stemming from the Declaration of the Peace
Implementation Council (PIC) held in Brussels in May 2000. It is also one of
the primary conditions for the accession of BiH to the Council of Europe and
for the fulfillment of the EU Roadmap. A Draft Election Law, prepared by a
group of experts under the joint auspices of OSCE and my Office, was adopted
by the CoM on 12 April and is currently pending before the Parliamentary
Assembly.
4. Removals
- This reporting period started with the full-blown
challenge to the constitutional order by the HDZ, which proclaimed the
so-called "Croat Self-Rule" In view of this, I decided to remove this party’s
leadership (four people), including Ante Jelavic, the Croat member of the
Presidency. Following the 6 April violence in Herzegovina, which is described
in detail in Chapter III, on 26 April I removed the Minister of Interior of
Canton 7 (Mostar), Dragan Mandic.
- All over the country, I dismissed two more public officials for serious
and persistent obstruction of the Peace Agreement Furthermore and I suspended
three officials for the same reasons. In addition, my policy of demanding the
authorities to dismiss themselves their obstructive officials, bore fruit in
May, when the RS Ministry of Interior’s top officials were forced to resign or
were dismissed following the violence in Banja Luka and Trebinje.
5. Civil Information Management and Documents
- My Office turned over the completed package of five
State laws dealing with the implementation of civil registries and issuance of
common identification cards and drivers licenses to the Ministry of Civil
Affairs and Communications (MCAC) in April 2001. This package also included a
State law on data protection that secures the rights of individuals regarding
the government use of the data, which meets the Council of Europe standards.
- The MCAC introduced these laws for governmental approval in May 2001 and
on 9 June the CoM adopted the laws and forwarded them to the Parliamentary
Assembly. Technical preparations with relevant State and Entity ministers are
nearly complete.
6. BiH in the European Integration Process
- Due to the inability of the Parliamentary Assembly to
get important legislation passed, the pace of the European integration
progress has been disappointing. A significant number of conditions remain to
be fulfilled on the EU’s Road Map, among them the adoption of the Civil
Service Law. In addition, the most important of the pre-accession criteria for
BiH’s accession to the Council of Europe, the adoption of an Election Law,
remains uncertain.
II. ECONOMY
1. General Overview of the BiH Economy
- A preliminary analysis indicates that BiH experienced
a GDP growth of approximately 5% in 2000. Predicted growth rates in the double
digits failed to materialize due to the fact that economic reforms are only
beginning to be implemented as well as to a severe drought.
- Net salaries increased in both Entities, contributing
positively to consumer demand. The inflation rate (retail price index)
continued at a very low level in the Federation and remained at a higher level
in the RS. The employment situation did not change substantially in 2001- a
level of 646,000 official jobs was maintained. However there is a persistently
high level of unemployed persons. In addition to the serious situation in the
social sector (high unemployment and low pension level payments), the problems
in the trade balance and the balance of payments are causes for concern.
2. Economic Reform
- Further economic reforms – particularly in
privatization of public utilities and restructuring – must be accelerated in
2001. While an increased inflow of foreign direct investment would facilitate
the restructuring of the economy, the creation of a favorable investment
climate remains a challenge for the BiH authorities. These are major
priorities, to which OHR has devoted a great deal of attention and resources,
following the recommendations of the PIC Steering Board.
a) Regional and European Economic Integration
- The Stability Pact provided a useful forum for
regional collaboration. My Office noted with satisfaction that the BiH
Ministry of European Integration has become a full and active partner in the
Pact’s economic activities held under the auspices of Working Table II on
Economic Reconstruction and Development. Further, it was confirmed that BiH
would assume the co-chairmanship of Working Table II for the second half of
2001.
- Accession to the EU remains the principal longer-term
political objective and economic aspiration. Key legislation required by the
EU Road Map, such as the Law on Consumer Protection and the Law on
Competition, are awaiting parliamentary approval.
b) Tax Reform
- My Office has taken a lead role in tax reform and,
through the IAG-T (International Advisory Group on Taxation), has accelerated
the process and improved co-ordination. The IMF project on harmonization of
the sales taxes was finished in April 2001 with an agreement between the two
entity governments. An agreement has been reached that the Brcko District
would harmonize its Sales Tax Law with the Entities no later than August 2001.
By January 2002, a harmonized Income Tax Law should be in place throughout
BiH.
c) Privatization
- In the RS, the voucher offer that began in November
of last year ended on 15 March. Citizens and 13 Privatization Investment Funds
(PIFs) were offered 55% of state equity in 830 enterprises. Of a total of 49
million vouchers issued, over 84% were utilized. In the Federation, the first
wave of Public Offering of Shares (POS’s) was completed on 28 March. A total
of 542 enterprises were offered to certificate holders, with the amount of
certificates subscribed at 4.25 billion KM.
- In the RS, the IC has committed to provide assistance
for 52 enterprises selected by the International Advisory Group on
Privatization (IAGP) for tender privatization. In the Federation, 86
enterprises were selected by the IAGP for tender privatization, with
consultant assistance being initiated by IC donors.
- In the fields of public utilities, public services,
infrastructure development and natural resource exploitation, public sector
participation (PSP) is usually arranged by way of concessions. An
Inter-Governmental Working Group, which had the full participation from the
BiH CoM, both Entities and international experts, completed its work in May
2001 and submitted fully-harmonized, draft concession laws to the BiH and
Entity governments for adoption.
d) Public Utilities
- The five-member, Prime Minister-level, BiH Commission
on Public Corporations (CPC) met on 17 April after a five-month hiatus. The
two new Entity PMs and the new Federation Deputy PM have assumed their role on
the Commission and agreed to move forward with work on the analysis and design
of new Annex 9 public corporations in the fields of gas transportation, power
transmission, radio transmission infrastructure and posts.
e) Transport
- The Railway Public Corporation (RPC), designed to
manage the railway infrastructure within BiH, is now legally registered in
both Entities. A 61 million Euro EBRD/EIB Railway Recovery Loan was signed on
11 June to re-construct 750 km of main track in BiH. On 4 May, my Office
organized a well-attended international conference on the BiH railway
situation, which concluded that the system must undergo drastic
re-organization to achieve an acceptable level of competitiveness and
effectiveness. As a tangible sign of its recovery, international passenger
service on the lines Sarajevo-Banja Luka-Zagreb and Doboj-Banja
Luka-Zagreb-Ljubljana re-opened on 10 June, after nine years of interruption.
- Both the Federation and RS have been in negotiations
with the EIB for a new Euro 60 million road improvement loan. The World Bank
is preparing a new Road Management and Safety Project worth USD 30 million,
which will focus on the corridor roads and address road maintenance and safety
problems.
f) Telecommunications Sector
- On 2 March, I issued a Decision establishing the
Communications Regulatory Agency (CRA), which combines the competencies of the
Independent Media Commission (IMC) and the Telecommunications Regulatory
Agency (TRA). The World Bank has offered technical assistance for sector
restructuring, privatization and other transition measures. This will cover
such areas as re-organizing the separated postal services, offering a
concession for the radio transmission infrastructure system and exploring
e-commerce opportunities. On 30 April the CRA granted national GSM licenses to
the two publicly owned mobile telephone operators, PTT-BiH and Mobilna Srpska
and launched the international competitive tendering process for a third
BiH-wide GSM license.
g) Energy Sector
- The adoption of new Electricity Laws by Entity
parliaments endorsing, among other things, a new State level regulatory
authority and the creation of a single power transmission corporation for BiH
are key conditions for obtaining World Bank (IDA) and EBRD approval for a
Power III Loan Project worth USD 230 million. Co-financing Power III is
expected to come from EIB, Switzerland, Norway, Germany, Spain, Italy and the
UK.
III. ANTI-CORRUPTION AND TRANSPARENCY ISSUES
- The emergence of the so-called ‘Croat Self-Rule’ and
its proclamation to take over Federation public revenues forced me to take
decisive action against the financial center of this illegal parallel
structure. The Hercegovacka Bank, founded and controlled by Croat hard-line
separatist elements through a circuitous ownership structure, served this
purpose as the collecting center for all public revenues taxed on
Croat-majority territory. My Office had also identified hidden accounts and
questionable loan practices to HDZ loyalists. On this basis, I proceeded to
place the bank under provisional administration in order to halt any illegal
activities occurring through the bank, as well as to protect the depositors’
interests. On April 6 the peaceful takeover of the bank by the Provisional
Administrator (PA), with the invaluable SFOR support, was resisted by violent
HDZ-organized riots, during which members of my staff working with the PA, as
well as several other internationals and BiH nationals, were injured,
threatened and taken hostage. A more robust follow-up action on 18 April,
again with SFOR backing, was a complete success.
- Following the Hercegovacka Bank operation on 6 April
and the criminal acts committed against the personnel assisting the PA, the
Federation authorities started an investigation, with the cooperation of the
IC. On 26 April I decided to transfer jurisdiction for the investigation and
prosecution of offences to the Cantonal Court of Sarajevo, because of the
well-grounded suspicions of local police involvement in the organized rioting
and the doubts about the local prosecutors and judges’ability to act
impartially in an environment of pressure and intimidation.
- The PA is faced with a lack of cooperation from the
shareholders and management. This has slowed down the consolidation of
accounts and hence the investigative process. Nevertheless, the work has gone
forward with specialist assistance, though the investigation will need time
before it can start delivering concrete results. The PA has undertaken
measures to secure the interests of especially the small deposit-holders.
Numerous meetings have been held with the shareholders and management and it
is hoped that progress will be made so that the future of the bank and its
account-holders can be decided. Besides freezing the bank’s deposits in the
Central Bank, the PA has sought to secure all overseas accounts so that these
resources are at the disposal of the depositors.
- Due to the lack of transparency and continuing suspicions of corruption in
public finances, I appointed a Special Auditor to audit and report on the
condition of government finances. The reports confirm that the system of
public finances is conducive to corruption and fraud, and that the appropriate
control mechanisms are lacking or are unable to fulfill their duties. As a
result, my Office is developing a strategy to reform the administrative
accounting procedures and strengthen the supreme audit, treasury and
parliamentary control mechanisms.
IV. RETURN
- The first five months of this year produced 30.123
"minority" returns (as registered by the UNHCR) indicating that this year’s
total is likely to be a significant improvement on the 67,000 "minority"
returns registered in 2000. However, obstacles stemming from the continuing
failure of local authorities to take full ownership of the process have
prevented a countrywide breakthrough. Although a State-level Ministry for
Human Rights and Refugees (MHRR) has been created, a stronger role in the
coordination of return-related issues between the Entities is necessary.
While the Federation budget now includes a substantial budget to support
returns, I also urged the RS PM to increase the RS Ministry for Refugees’
budget and to re-focus it towards Bosniac and Croat returns to RS -and Serb
to the Federation- instead of only supporting Serb DP’s who wish to stay in
RS. On several occasions I have used my Annex 10 powers to warn mayors who
obstruct returns and on 1 June, I decided to remove the Mayor and the Head
of the Housing Office of Bratunac (Eastern RS) for their continued
obstruction of the return process in his municipality.
- The RRTF (Reconstruction and Return Task Force),
with its Economic and Human Rights counterparts, are increasing their focus
on sustainability, in particular equal access to economic opportunities.
Returnees’ efforts to acquire documentation, employment, education and
pensions remain problematic. My Office is also working to ensure that
returnees can access basic utilities under fair and equal conditions.
- Refugee return remains negatively affected by the
situation in Croatia and the FRY, although there has been some legislative
progress recently in Croatia. Overall progress is not sufficient to enable
uninterrupted and smooth return. The obstacles include the lack of a
transparent legal framework for the repossession of property. Therefore,
some 25,000 Croatian Serbs in the western RS continue to await resolution of
their status, creating a tough obstacle to Croat and Bosniac return to RS.
With regard to return from the FRY to BiH, this is being addressed by the
efforts of my Office to improve the overall situation for property
repossession in BiH, and through efforts to increase cooperation and
dialogue between FRY, BiH and Croatia.
V. PROPERTY
- According to PLIP statistics, as of the end of May
2001, 51% of property claims have been decided on and 27% resulted in actual
repossessions. These results represent an important benchmark in the
implementation of property legislation that I imposed in 1999.
- However, the increase in the rate of implementation
of the property laws remains too slow and currently stands at 2% per month
in the Federation and 1% in the RS. Local authorities in both Entities will
have to significantly accelerate the rate of implementation of property
legislation, especially in Eastern RS and, in the Federation, in Cantons 7
(Mostar) and 10 (Livno).
VI. EDUCATION
- Ministerial commitments and/or commencement of implementation of the
following issues have been achieved by my Office during this reporting
period:
- Courses in "Human Rights and Civic education" will
replace "Civil Defense";
- Classes devoted to the literature of the other constituent peoples of BiH
and language modules focusing on their common linguistic heritage and
linguistic diversity today are to be prepared for February 2002;
- The subject "Culture of Religions" is to be
introduced in September 2002;
- Teaching of the two alphabets is obligatory in both
entities as from the second semester of the current school year 2001 (from
grade 2 of primary school);
- Textbooks imported from Belgrade and Zagreb, which do
not refer to BiH, will be phased out by September 2002;
- A majority of the Federation Cantons are now willing
to devolve part of their responsibilities and powers to the Federation
Ministry of Education in order to facilitate strategic education planning in
the future;
- The inter-entity Educational Standards and Assessment Agency, established
by the World Bank, has finally been operationalised.
VII. MEDIA
- The International Chief Executive of the CRA, who
started his mandate in mid-February, has successfully combined the staff and
business operations of the CRA's two predecessor organizations, IMC and TRA.
Additionally, CRA is continuing the merit-based long-term broadcast
licensing process begun by the IMC. Although problems with implementation
cannot be ruled out as the licensing process moves into more politically
volatile areas, the process has started well, with 100% compliance in the
first region covered. The BiH Communications Law, which will provide a legal
basis and structural foundation for the CRA, was presented to the CoM on 24
April for consideration.
- The restructuring of the Public Broadcasting System
(PBS) in BiH continues with the simultaneous launch on 7 May of both PBS
radio (broadcasting across the whole territory of BiH) and Federation radio.
For the first time since the disintegration of the former Yugoslavia, BiH
has a statewide broadcasting capability. The citizens of BiH now have a
forum available to all, irrespective of ethnicity, to debate crucial issues
of the day, free from political subversion and distortion. Currently the PBS
radio signal is accessible to approximately 72% of the population. Work to
extend the coverage to 85% of the population will continue during autumn
2001, subject to available donor funding.
- The Federation Parliament adopted in June the Draft
Defamation Act. I expect the final vote to be taken at the Parliament’s next
session in July. In the RS, the Proposed Defamation Act should be considered
in the very near future. Following adoption, it will forward the Proposed
Act to the RS National Assembly for the final vote.
- The draft Law on Freedom of Access to Information, prepared by an expert
group in coordination with the OSCE and OHR in October 2000, was adopted at
the State level, as well as by both the Federation and RS
Governments.
- JUDICIAL REFORM
- On 14 March, I issued a decision providing the
Independent Judicial Commission (IJC) with a comprehensive mandate embracing
matters regarding the promotion of the rule of law and judicial reform. I
followed this with an internal directive clarifying the scope of
administrative competencies and powers as between my Office and the IJC.
Thus, the basic framework for the IJC is now set. During this period, the
IJC has significantly increased its staffing and has been able to begin
working on the various issues that fall within its mandate. The Director
took up office on 2 April. The IJC is now established in its own
headquarters in Sarajevo and in four field offices (Banja Luka, Mostar,
Sarajevo, and Tuzla). I expect the fifth office in Bihac to open soon.
- The IJC has started the implementation of its
strategic plan for the next twelve months and has identified some areas or
particular importance to the strengthening of the rule of law in BiH: review
of the laws on appointment of judges and prosecutors, criminal and civil
procedure reform, review of legislation on enforcement of civil judgements
and court administration and management.
- During the period, there was some progress in these
areas, especially with the increased activity of local working groups on law
reform issues. I am encouraged to see that there is an acknowledged
recognition by the Ministers of Justice of each Entity of the benefits of
harmonizing their legislation in key areas, such as procedural laws, and of
the need for some problems to be resolved at State-level.
- The IJC has been monitoring and guiding the work of the national
commissions and councils established to improve the process of recruitment
of judges and prosecutors and to carry out a comprehensive review of all
serving judges and prosecutors. However, political obstruction in certain
areas has continued to impede the appointment of prosecutors.
IX HUMAN RIGHTS
1. Human Rights institutions
a) BiH Human Rights Ombudsman
- The Mostar "Liska Street" incident of February 1997
-denounced by the UN SG-, in which a Bosniac was killed and twenty were
injured during a visit to a cemetery for the Bajram, is now under criminal
investigation by Mostar judicial authorities, pursuant to recommendations
contained in a Special Report of the BiH Ombudsman.
b) Entity Ombudsman Institutions
- In annual reports released during the reporting
period, the RS and Federation institutions highlighted that the top two
issues about which individuals register complaints concerned failures to be
able to repossess one's pre-war housing, and ethnic discrimination
concerning employment.
c) Human Rights Chamber
- The implementation rate for the decisions of the
Human Rights Chamber (HRC) has increased and now stands at 75%, up from 33%
at the end of 1999. Similar increases have also been seen with reports of
the BiH Human Rights Ombudsman.
- In order to properly implement the HRC decision demanding the
reconstruction of the Ferhadija mosque in Banja Luka, the "urban permit"
(originally issued on 22 November 2000) was amended by the local authorities
in March 2001.
2. Social, Economic and Gender Rights
- My Office is developing policies and strategies
aimed at remedying the current discriminatory practices in healthcare,
access to utilities and employment. It has continued to monitor the
implementation of the Entity Labour Laws regarding possible re-employment or
compensation for those who were dismissed during the war, and continues to
present the principle of conditionality to donor agencies in an effort to
establish an equitable employment market. My Office has helped facilitate a
system of pension transfer, whereby returnee pensioners can receive their
pensions in the place of return, thus facilitating sustainable return all
over BiH.
- As the trafficking of persons in and through BiH
persists, my Office continues to participate in the Working Group to Combat
Trafficking in Human Beings. It has drafted a BiH Plan of Action to Combat
Trafficking in Human Beings, which is pending before the Parliamentary
Assembly of BiH.
- My Office is participating in the review of draft legislation pertaining
to the rights of national minorities and gender equality. Members of my
staff participate in the recently established Roma Coordination Group, with
members from the IC and the Roma community, in an effort to address the
widespread discrimination of this often over-looked minority.
3. ICTY
- My Office has continued to cooperate closely with
ICTY, in order to assist with the facilitation of its mandate. In
particular, it has worked with ICTY in commenting on the RS Draft Law on
Co-operation with ICTY and the BiH Draft Law on the Truth and Reconciliation
Commission. Additionally, it has continued to attract investors to support
the activities of ICTY’s Rules of the Road Unit, principally their proposal
for a lecture series involving legal training for members of the BiH
judiciary and police force involved in the prosecution of alleged war
criminals.
- It has continued to monitor compliance with the Rules of the Road
Agreement and domestic war-crimes trials.
4. Missing persons and Potocari (Srebrenica) memorial site
- The specific boundaries of the Potocari site, which
I designated in October 2000 for the burial and commemoration of the victims
of the 1995 Srebrenica massacre, were identified and eventually marked in
March.
- In order to organise and focus the development of the site, the
Foundation for the Srebrenica/Potocari Memorial and Cemetery was created and
registered. In anticipation of the 6th anniversary of the massacre, the
Foundation has agreed on a design and location for a stone to mark the
site.
- LEGAL ISSUES
1. State Institutions: Civil Service and State Court
- My Office, in collaboration with the EU, is seeking
adoption by the CoM of the draft Law on the Civil Service. In order to
ensure the effective implementation of such legislation, an Agency for Civil
Service will be established. This administrative authority will actively
contribute to a professional and standardized recruitment and dismissal
process of the civil servants.
- The Court of BiH, put into law by my Decision of last November, has not
yet become operative, because of RS litigation before the BiH Constitutional
Court on its constitutionality.
2. Issues Related to the BiH Constitutional Court’s Decisions
- On 23 March, the BiH Constitutional Court found
itself competent to review the constitutionality of the legislation that I
imposed. It found the Law on Travel Documents -providing for a single BiH
passport- that I imposed on 29 September 2000 to be consistent with the BiH
Constitution.
- The Constitutional Commissions in both Entities are
progressing in the preparation of proposals for the amendments of the Entity
constitutions in accordance with last year’s Constituent People’s Decision
of the BiH Constitutional Court. Although OHR observers are present at
commission meetings, the process is very much left to their own
responsibility at this stage. Both Commissions have come to agreements on
most issues. In RS, the constituent peoples’ vital interest will probably be
protected by a Commission. In the Federation, the Constitutional Commission
has left options for the Federation Parliament on sensitive issues such as
the new parliamentary structure, including any "vital interest" protection
mechanism.
- The process in the Federation has been considerably delayed by the
general attitude of the HDZ. Although I invited this party on numerous
occasions to participate in the work of the Constitutional Commissions, it
refused the invitation, following its pattern of anti-constitutional
behaviour. Eventually, I was forced to appoint Croat members from other
political parties.
3. Other legal issues
- In February I issued a Decision imposing binding
arbitration on the RS and the Federation aimed at finally resolving the long
standing dispute over the precise delineation of the IEBL in the Dobrinja
suburb of Sarajevo. The appointed Arbitrator finalized the arbitration
process and the Award was issued on 24 April. The resolution of this issue
will not only have a positive impact on the return of former Dobrinja
residents to their homes, but will also create a positive environment for
the full implementation of Annex 7 to the GFAP.
- I am pleased to report that BiH is reforming the
legal aspects of public water management in accordance with European Union
directives and principles of international law.
- My Office is currently pressing for the adoption of
the Federation Law on Citizenship by the Federation Parliament. It is now
for review under an urgent procedure. Its adoption is indeed crucial, since
many former citizens of the SFRY who took up permanent residence in BiH
before 1998 became eligible for BiH citizenship as of 1 January 2000 and are
unable to do so in the absence of a Federation Citizenship Law.
- Under my separate mandate for SFRY succession, I mediated the final
round of the negotiations on succession to the SFRY, together with the
Special Negotiator, Sir Arthur Watts. On 25 May, the five successor states
(BiH, Croatia, FYR of Macedonia, Slovenia, and FRY) initialed an agreement
that provided for the distribution of the SFRY’s rights, obligations, assets
and liabilities.
.
- MILITARY ISSUES
1. Defence and Military Reform; Development of a State-level Defence
Institution
- Although I still consider the overall process
towards BiH armed forces integration and the building of a State level
security and defence identity too slow, a significant step was taken on 11
May when the BiH Presidency adopted a BiH Defence Policy (DP). Its adoption
has clearly strengthened the authority of the Presidency in the area of
defence and security. This in turn is expected to strengthen the position
and authority of the Standing Committee on Military Matters (SCMM) and its
Secretariat.
2. Re-structuring of the Entity Armed Forces
- Under the lead of SFOR, both Entities’ armed forces
have now achieved the necessary 15% reduction in size. The re-structuring
work is now being taken forward under the guidance of the Joint Military
Commission, which engages representatives from both BiH and the IC.
3. De-mining
- Following the publication on 23 March of the
Federation Finance Police report into corruption within the de-mining
operations, confidence has started to return among donors. Some pledges have
been received, notably from Germany, USA, Canada, Sweden and Slovenia, which
will provide for over half of the required 2001 budget. However, more funds
are required and other donor nations would like to see a greater
contribution from within BiH to show a commitment equal to that of the IC.
Furthermore, some pledges have not yet been converted to actual funding.
Joint Chairs of the Boards of Donors have written to the MCAC offering
advice on how both of these problems may be addressed.
- The Demining Commission is pushing ahead with the
drafting of a De-mining Law to streamline the structure of the de-mining
organization (something that the IC is keen to see), avoid redundancies and
create a legal basis for de-mining activities within BiH.
4. Civil Aviation
- The new CoM accepted the advice of my Office, SFOR and ICAO and
established a CoM Working Group (WG) for Civil Aviation. At the 14 June
session of the International Standing Committee for BiH in Sarajevo,
following considerable effort from my Office and ICAO to provide technical
and political advice to the CoM, the recommendations of the WG for the
transfer of authority from SFOR to civil aviation in BiH, were approved. In
essence, it was agreed that:
- BiH should join the Central European Air Traffic
Services (CEATS) for the provision of air traffic services in the upper air
space;
- Provision of air traffic services in middle and lower airspace should
temporarily be contracted to a single service provider, Croatia Control
Limited (CCL), for as long as NATO controls operational military flights in
that airspace.
OHR Report of the High Representative
18 July 2001
|