![]() |
Other Policy Documents | |
| | 1/11/2005 | ||
|
HR's Reports Report to the European Parliament by the OHR and EU Special Representative for BiH, June - December 2004
|
||
Summary In its tenth year of Dayton/Paris implementation, In the reporting period OHR continued to support the BiH institutions’ efforts to take on greater responsibilities, focussing on the core reforms required to fulfil the Mission Implementation Plan (MIP). Towards this end, the OHR’s priorities over the past 6 months focused on improving the operation and effectiveness of BiH’s governing institutions. The OHR’s draft MIP for 2005, submitted to the Peace Implementation Council contains 108 items to be completed, 102 of them before end-2005. The European Commission (EC) Feasibility Study conditions for opening negotiations on a Stabilisation and Association Agreement with BiH dominated the political developments in the second half of 2004. The BiH authorities made steady progress towards fulfilling the legislative requirements in the reporting period, while implementation lagged behind. Significant progress was still needed in key areas such as ICTY co-operation, tackling crime, and improving the economy. Despite remarkable progress in defence reform, placing the armed forces under state control and fulfilling almost all NATO’s military reform benchmarks, BiH failed to make the cut for PfP-membership. Full co-operation with the ICTY remained the overwhelming stumbling block. Both the ICTY Chief Prosecutor and NATO Ministers cited fundamental systemic weaknesses built into BIH’s law enforcement security structures as a central part of the problem. BIH’s failure to meet the requirements for PfP, and the Republika Srpska’s
special responsibility in this regard, prompted the OHR and the
The Council of the European Union decided on a) to provide deterrence, continued compliance with the responsibility to fulfil the role specified in Annexes 1A and 2 of the Dayton/Paris Agreement (General Framework Agreement for Peace in BiH); and b) to contribute to a safe and secure environment in BiH, in line with its mandate, required to achieve core tasks in the OHR's Mission Implementation Plan and the Stabilisation and Association process (SAp). The OHR continued to work on building the capacities of the State Court during the second half of 2004. In the reporting period OHR closely with the ICTY and the appropriate BiH Authorities to establish the necessary institutions for the domestic trial of war crimes in BiH by establishing a special department for war crimes within the State Prosecutor’s Office and a special chamber for war crimes within the State Court. Since the adoption of the laws establishing SIPA in July 2004, the agency has moved towards full operationalisation. In the second half of 2004 SIPA became the primary agency in BiH responsible for compiling and analysing information from financial transactions in order to initiate appropriate criminal investigations. The High Judicial and Prosecutorial Council came into being as a state-level
institution on Noteworthy progress was made on economic reform as well, with the BiH authorities assuming increasing ownership. The BIH authorities made significant progress towards implementing a single set of tax rules, applicable throughout the country. In the final quarter of 2004 a remarkable success was achieved in re-balancing of the BiH governments’ budgets. December 2004 also saw the adoption of entity budgets for 2005. BiH moved closer to the establishment of a single economic space. The establishment of the Intelligence-Security Agency (OSA) proceeded as foreseen in the transitional provisions as set forth in the Law on OSA. At Prime Minister Terzić’s initiative, a Police Restructuring Commission
(PRC) was established in July with a mandate to propose “a single structure of
policing for Significant progress has been achieved in unifying the city of
In a historical development, Mostar’s Stari Most, or
Political developments The reporting period saw the first municipal elections to be administered
wholly by local institutions, in October 2004. The elections were well
organised, even if characterised by a relatively low (45 %) turnout.. In the
Federation, the predominantly Muslim SDA maintained its position as the lead
party amongst the Bosniak parties, both in terms of number of votes and vote
share; the predominantly Croat HDZ pulled off a solid victory as well. In the
RS, the SNSD (led by Dodik) emerged as a relative winner gaining a higher number
of votes than the The period immediately after the elections saw an increase in tensions between the parties of the Federation government. Relations between SBIH and SDA were particularly strained but, following some public posturing, SBIH agreed to stay in government. Across both Entities, and irrespective of ethnicity, the direct election of mayors saw a higher vote for individual candidates than for political parties. During the final months of 2004, the RS leadership showed signs of recognising that the International Community’s determination to ensure full ICTY co-operation would not diminish. In late October the RS Government adopted the Srebrenica Commission’s final report, acknowledging for the first time the crimes committed by the RS Army in Srebrenica in 1995. Significantly, the RS Presidency offered an apology as part of its response to the Report. The IC lauded this step and called on the RS to bring those guilty of war crimes to justice. In addition RS Special Police arrested eight Bosnian Serbs on suspicion of
war crimes, although they were not ICTY indictees. The warrant was issued by the
Subsequent to that, the OHR and the The measures included:
In response to these measures, PDP ministers at RS and BiH level (including
the RS Prime Minister and the BiH Foreign Minister) submitted their resignations
(the Foreign Minster subsequently withdrew his resignation). RS President
Dragan Cavic convened all Serb-dominated parties talks on the way forward and in
December the heads of 6 Serb-based parties signed an Agreement that inter
alia confirmed the RS’s commitment to tackling the ICTY issue.
Eventually, in January 2005, RS authorities transferred their first
ICTY-indictee to
The 2004 MIP contained 4 core tasks, made up of 26 programmes. Of the 26 programmes, 4 were completed in full: Reinforcement of the Rule of Law by Dislodging Obstructionist Networks from Key Institutions; BiH State Management of Identity Documents; BiH Parliamentary Oversight over the Armed Forces; and BiH Security Policy. Approximately 50% of all items contained in the 26 programmes were completed at the end of 2004, within the set deadlines. A draft revised MIP has been submitted to the Peace Implementation Council containing 102 items to be completed by the end of 2005. A further six items (five by February and one item – Oversee first phase of local police demobilisation – by December 2006) are targeted to be completed in 2006. The revised MIP will reflect six core institutional priorities necessary to set BiH irreversibly on the path to self-sustainability: Council of Ministers (CoM); Indirect Taxation Authority (ITA) and VAT; State Court and Prosecutor’s Office; Police Reform; Intelligence Reform; and Defence Reform
Entrenching the Rule of Law The OHR continued to work on building the capacities of the State Court during the second half of 2004. OHR’s Rule of Law team supervised the recruitment of international judges and prosecutors for the Special Panel on Organised and Financial Crimes within the State Court. OHR also played a crucial role in creating a domestic capacity for trying war crimes, through the establishment of a Special Department for War Crimes within the State Prosecutor’s Office and a special chamber and a Registrar’s Office in the State Court. Enabling legislation and international agreements were enacted in the final months of 2004, following nearly two years of intensive preparations and fundraising. The ICTY President and Chief Prosecutor and their teams played an invaluable role in bringing this to fruition. Efforts to develop a sound anti-money laundering programme have progressed as well. After the adoption of the new Law on Prevention of Money Laundering and the establishment of SIPA with a Financial Intelligence Department (FID), SIPA became the primary agency in BiH responsible for compiling and analysing information from financial transactions in order to initiate appropriate criminal investigations. Long-standing efforts to develop the means to seize assets acquired through or used in criminal activities resulted in the drafting of a law to be enacted at state level in order to make such a sanction available to the state prosecutor. This law is currently being reviewed and considered by a working group created by the Minister of Justice. The creation of the State Court and the State Prosecutor’s Office and the
arrival of international judges and prosecutors to help staff them enabled OHR
to dissolve its Rule of Law Pillar on The OHR’s Rule of Law Department continues to work closely with the EUPM, the European Commission and other partners to position SIPA as a full-fledged, state-level police agency with the resources and authority to combat organised and international crime, corruption and terrorism. Since the adoption of the laws establishing SIPA in July 2004, the agency has moved quickly towards full operationalisation. By the end of the year, SIPA had recruited nearly 30 percent of its staff and made operational its Departments for Criminal Investigations, Financial Intelligence, Witness Protection and War Crimes. In November, with the assistance of SFOR, SIPA arrested a person indicted for war crimes by a domestic court. This was the first such operation involving the state-level police force. Moreover, SIPA’s criminal inspectors have been assisting the Prosecutor's Office in a number of financial and organised crime cases. SIPA was expected to achieve full capacity by end-2005. BiH still lacked modern criminal intelligence capabilities. This deficiency
seriously impaired its ability to deal effectively with organised crime and
corruption. The OHR’s Criminal Intelligence Unit (CIU) began work in 2004, with
SIPA and its EUPM advisers, to develop this capacity within the Criminal
Investigations Department ( The state, entity and Brčko District governments agreed in early 2004 to form a single High Judicial and Prosecutorial Council (HJPC) to serve them all. Although the new HJPC has no formal relationship with OHR, it will continue to work closely with the Rule of Law and Legal Departments on issues of common interest. The HJPC-led process of re-appointing all judges and prosecutors at all levels in BiH required a massive effort, spanning most of the year 2004. Almost 1,000 vacancies were advertised. Over 1,700 applications were received and reviewed. Candidates were vetted in a procedure that included thorough background investigations. More than 900 candidates were interviewed. The result was the appointment (or reappointment) of 877 judges and prosecutors. Only those positions for which the number and calibre of candidates were inadequate remain to be filled. The problem of judicial salaries remains troublesome. Judicial salaries are grossly disproportionate to salaries of other government officials. In many instances, judicial salaries consume as much as eighty or ninety percent of the entire court budget, rendering the courts literally unable to pay their operating expenses and resulting in the complete dysfunction of the courts. OHR has worked with the HJPC to redress this problem. A solution should be possible during early 2005. BiH continued to struggle to provide adequate prison facilities that met international humanitarian standards. Although pre-trial confinement facilities had been constructed as part of the war crimes project, state-level facilities were still missing for the confinement of those convicted by the State Court. Thus far, this problem had been addressed by detaining State prisoners in Entity penal facilities. These Entity facilities were reaching capacity, however, and the manner in which they were maintained and operated had given rise to serious human rights concerns. A failure to identify local and international funds to create of new penal facilities could severely constrain work of both the Special Chamber for War Crimes and the Special Chamber for Organised Crime, Financial Crime and Corruption unless it is resolved.
Reforming the economyThe BiH economy will soon begin to experience benefits from the various legal, fiscal and structural reforms undertaken in recent years. Domestic authorities and the non-governmental actors are assuming increasing ownership, particularly in the areas of fiscal reform and improvement of the overall business environmental. During the reporting period, the BiH authorities made significant strides
towards implementing a single set of tax rules, applicable throughout the
country. In December, state-level laws on sales and excise taxation were passed.
Hence, for the first time since the signing of the GFAP in 1995, the same
indirect tax rates, rules, enforcement regulations and collection system will
operate across the whole country. At the same time, the problem of double
taxation within the The final quarter of 2004 witnessed a remarkable success in rebalancing the BiH governments’ budgets. The new budgetary arrangements for 2005 will see a great bulk of the public revenues being collected into a single account before being re-apportioned in accordance with an agreement concluded in December between the state and entity finance ministers, with the IMF’s approval. Further important steps have been taken to complete the establishment of a single economic space and create a level playing field for all businesses. The state-level Law on Public Procurement was adopted in autumn. The new BiH Law on Accounting and Auditing will, inter alia, put in place a uniform set of international accounting and auditing standards. These changes will improve the reporting standards of BiH companies and hopefully make BiH more accessible and attractive to foreign investors. Longstanding efforts to reform and restructure the transport sector continue to yield mixed results. Although progress was made in civil aviation, circumstances beyond BiH authorities’ and the OHR’s control limited the scope for further improvement. BiH’s civil aviation sector continues to lose millions of Euros per year in over-flight fees due to the continued closure of the air space over Kosovo. Ever since the 1992-1995 war, the European electricity sector has been divided into two grids – with the border running through BiH. On 10 October, an historic event took place when these two grids were finally reconnected. Thus physical reconstruction and institutional reform in BiH came together to help re-create the biggest synchronous electricity supply zone in the world.[1] Further ongoing reforms in the energy sector in BiH should result in the compliance with the EU Electricity Directive, creating the basis for a functional regional energy market. The BIH State Veterinary Border Inspection Service was launched in November, with the OHR’s assistance. This will create new opportunities for BiH producers to export their agricultural products. Given that the overwhelming proportion of BiH citizens’ livelihoods depends on farming and food processing, this is a significant achievement. Alarming patterns of mismanagement, incompetence and political gerrymandering persisted in publicly owned companies in the RS. Therefore, in December,the High Representative changed key legislation, requiring compulsory special audits of such companies. In response, both Entity governments committed themselves to implementing reforms aimed at improving management practices and eliminating endemic corruption. The passage of the BiH Law on Public Procurement in September put in place uniform procurement regulations for all levels of government, in line with the EU’s acquis communautaire.
Strengthening the capacity of BiH’s governing institutions, especially at the State-level On
Establishing State-level civilian command and control over armed forces, reform the security sector, and paving the way for integration into the Euro-Atlantic framework Progress in defence reform continued, fulfilling of all but one of NATO’s 13 technical benchmarks for entry into PfP. BiH’s failure to cooperate fully with the ICTY prevented NATO from extending a PfP invitation at its 8-9 December Brussels Ministerial. NATO’s foreign ministers underlined once again that BiH and its neighbours must cooperate fully with the ICTY, and that BiH would be welcome in PfP only when it had met the established conditions. NATO’s “no” to PfP resulted in a waning enthusiasm for defence reform on the part of BiH authorities. As the reform process entered deeper into the implementation phase, technical issues surfaced more frequently and some momentum was lost. While substantial progress was still achieved, the process had shifted into a lower gear – at least temporarily. Several accomplishments deserve mention, however. During the period of
review, the Armed Forces of Bosnia and
Concepts have been agreed for a military intelligence branch within the AFBiH as well, with strong State oversight and a State de-mining cell. A moratorium on the sale of surplus small arms and light weapons was introduced, a technical survey and a pilot programme for the destruction of surplus arms and ammunition were completed, and a plan for a substantial reduction of the number of ammunition storage sites was drafted. The first BiH defence minister, Nikola Radovanovic, in office since April 2004, continued to play an important and constructive role. The High Representative’s measures announced on Since the Intelligence-Security Agency’s (OSA) was established in June 2004, the physical and organisational unification of the two former entity intelligence services has proceeded as foreseen in the Law on OSA. At Prime Minister Adnan Terzić’s initiative, a Police Restructuring
Commission (PRC) was established on 5 July with a mandate to propose “a single
structure of policing for Implementation of the recommendations of this report will be a major priority for 2005.
BiH in the region Growing international pressure on
The visit of Serbian President Boris Tadic in BiH at the end of 2004, and his public apology "for those who committed crimes in the name of the Serb people" sent a strong signal. During the course of this visit, the BiH Presidency and the Serbian president officially affirmed their countries’ common goal of EU and PfP membership. However, the refusal by BiH to withdraw its complaint against
In BiH’s presidency of the South-East European Co-operation Process (SEECP), including the first meeting of defence ministers from the region, demonstrated BiH’s capacity to play a valuable political role at the regional level, as well as the utility of SEECP as an inter-state forum.
BiH and the European rapprochement process
EC Feasibility Study The EC’s Feasibility Study requirements dominated the BiH’s reform agenda during the reporting period. The BiH authorities made considerable progress during 2004 towards fulfilling the legislative requirements of the EC’s Feasibility Study. Twenty-seven state agencies were established and 42 new laws were adopted, many of which introduce significant structural changes in the fields of crime prevention, the judiciary, customs and taxation, developing a single economic space and the energy market. Although the majority of legislative steps had been completed by the end of 2004, the EC was not yet ready to declare ‘significant progress’ across the 16 priority areas listed in the FS. The main focus for the coming months will be on the implementation of the adopted legislation, required by the FS. In addition to the key stumbling blocks such as full co-operation with ICTY and police restructuring, internal market related issues (energy, customs, and taxation), tackling crime, public broadcasting, statistics, and regional trade remained issues of concern.
Transition from SFOR to EUFOR / Operation Althea The Council of the European Union decided on This military operation, named EUFOR / Operation Althea was launched on
a) to provide deterrence, continued compliance with the responsibility to fulfil the role specified in Annexes 1A and 2 of the Dayton/Paris Agreement (General Framework Agreement for Peace in BiH); and b) to contribute to a safe and secure
environment in BiH, in line with its mandate, required to achieve core tasks in
the OHR's Mission Implementation Plan and the Stabilisation and Association
Process ( On 22 November 2004 the UN Security Council adopted Resolution 1575 defining the mandate of EUFOR and the NATO Headquarters, enabling the 25 November 2004 EU Council officially to launch EUFOR / Operation Althea. With the handover from SFOR to EUFOR on EU and NATO planners worked closely together in the months leading up to the transfer of authority. Their shared objective of a ‘seamless transition’ was achieved. EUFOR operates with approximately the same force size, the same task force structure, and the same basic mandate, resources and commitment to ensure peace and stability in BiH as SFOR did. But EUFOR is also a vital additional part of the EU family. It will add in a significant way to the EU's political engagement, its assistance programmes and its ongoing police and monitoring missions with a view to helping BiH make further progress towards European integration in the context of the Stabilisation and Association Process. As such, EUFOR reinforces the EU’s integrated efforts in BiH, and helps enable the country to progress towards EU integration by its own efforts. For BiH, the launch of Operation Althea marked the beginning of a new
phase in its recovery as well – its transition from the era of Dayton/Paris to
the era of These developments also testified to the deepened co-operation between the EU
and NATO. On the ground, EUFOR and the new NATO HQ are co-located in
EUPM During the past six months the State Ministry of Security achieved notable progress in recruiting staff and establishing internal departments covering all their areas of responsibility. The Minister of Security took over the chairmanship of the Ministerial Consultative Meeting on Police Matters (MCMPM - originally established by the UNMiBH/IPTF), which co-ordinates and oversees the political aspects of all the state-level police agencies. In the past six months a series of important new laws were drafted and adopted, with EUPM advice, including a law that created and regulated a new Immigration Service, an updated law governing the working of the State Border Service (SBS) and a Law on Police Officials. An expanded team of EUPM advisers were created to provide support and give expert advice on police matters. The State Investigation and Protection Agency was established in temporary
accommodation in
In EUPM continued to work with the BiH authorities on ways to achieve financial viability and sustainability of the local police. Progress in this area would enable the Public Security Centres in the RS and the Police Administration in the Federation of BiH MoI to operate more effectively next year, benefiting e.g. from an improved fiscal methodology. The EUPM contributed significantly to police restructuring during the reporting period. Its Head of Mission served as a full member of the Police Restructuring Commission (PRC) and contributed greatly to the Chairman’s final report. The EUPM also seconded personnel to the Commission’s Secretariat.
EU Special Representative (EUSR) In addition to his mandate as the High Representative, Lord Ashdown also
serves as the European Union Special Representative in
The main activities of the Lord Ashdown during the reporting period, in his
capacity as EUSR, focused on implementing the EU’s Comprehensive Policy for
In July 2004 the EUSR launched an EUSR website ( www.eusrbih.org, in English, Bosnian, Croatian, and Serbian), which is the first and only website amongst EUSRs. The website features up-to-the-minute news regarding EUSR’s activities and strategic priorities. The website has a full-text search engine and offers users the possibility of receiving daily email updates on the work of the EUSR. Under the leadership of the EUSR’s Head of Communications, a European Union family web portal (www.eubih.org) was also launched in December. The aim of the portal was to present individual EU organisations in BiH. It explains the work of the Office of the EUSR, the EU-led military mission EUFOR, the EU-led police mission EUPM and the European Commission.[2] The EUSR Team has been constituted. Key positions remain vacant, however, due to the lack of secondment offers and legal obstacles to direct recruitment. Outstanding legal issues related to privileges, immunities and indemnity are in the process of being addressed with the Council Secretariat and the Commission. The main challenges for the next six months are to continue to focus
attention to the implementation of requirements set out by the EC in its
Feasibility Study. Satisfying these requirements is one of the major strategic
priorities for BiH, and the EU will need to continue to support the BiH
authorities in their efforts to meet their objectives. The EUSR will also seek
to further enhance co-ordination and coherence of EU action/instruments,
including providing political guidance and other support, as appropriate, to
EUFOR and EUPM. The EUSR will also assist in offering political advice on
key issues such as ICTY co-operation and police restructuring. The EUSR
will further seek to engage member states and institutions in discussions on the
future of the OHR and a possible transition to an EUSR-led mission, recognising
that decisions about the future of the OHR are ultimately a matter for the
[1]The
[2]The EUMM does not have its own website and is therefore referenced under the EUSR’s website.
| ||
| Emerika Bluma 1, 71000 Sarajevo; Tel: +387 33 283 500, Fax: +387 33 283 501 | www.ohr.int | |