Thank you for inviting me to join this discussion on the future
of Sarajevo University. It is a centre of learning which can look back on a
distinguished history, and with imagination and wise management, it can take its
place again among the best European universities. However, instituting reform
and sweeping away the unacceptable habits which have accrued during a long and
trying period of war and stagnation is not something that can be considered at
leisure. Improving the quality of Higher Education, in Sarajevo and in Bosnia
and Herzegovina as a whole, must be accomplished without delay. Young people are
leaving the country, or wish to leave the country. One of the avenues they
believe are closed to them is a first class university education.
Bosnia and Herzegovina has still to become a signatory to the
Lisbon Convention on the recognition of Higher Education qualifications. If
academic qualifications are not accepted, inside the country and outside, they
are reduced to the level of mail-order degrees. The failure to secure domestic
and international recognition for academic qualifications represents an
unforgivable disservice to the student body - it devalues the currency of their
hard work, it reduces their job prospects and it reduces their chances of
gaining knowledge and skills overseas which can then be put in the service of
Bosnia and Herzegovina when they return home. The Entity Ministries of Education
are committed to signing the Lisbon Convention before the end of 2002. They must
do so.
In 1999, 29 European education ministers signed the Bologna
Declaration, committing themselves to the creation of a common European
education space within a period of ten years. The principal practical
instruments of the Bologna process are the European Credit Transfer System,
which now operates across the whole of Europe in a growing number of
universities, and Quality Assurance schemes which help develop comparable
criteria and methodologies. In September, Bosnia and Herzegovina agreed to
prepare an implementation plan to be presented to the secreteriat of the Bologna
process.Completion and acceptance of the plan will allow BiH to become a
signatory to the treaty. Implementation of the plan will allow BiH students
eventually to take advantage of this system. The plan, which ought to be
developed by all the universities, was supposed to have been coordinated by the
Ministries and presented by now. It has yet to be completed.
At the administrative level, the system of allocating funds
from the cantonal Education budget directly to university faculties, rather than
to the university as a whole, means that public money is not used transparently
or efficiently; funds are not allocated according to performance and need, and
university administrators are denied the capacity to plan and spend in a
strategic way.
Management of state owned university property is equally
inefficient; some Faculties with relatively few students dispose of excessive
space while Faculties with large numbers of students are crammed into inadequate
and underequipped facilities
The result is, not surprisingly, profound student
dissatisfaction. Recently, a protest was organised by students at the Political
Science faculty in Sarajevo. They complained that some professors don’t turn up
for lessons. They also complained about situations where students turn up for
exams at nine in then morning, hang about until two in the afternoon and are
then told that the exam has been postponed. And they claimed that some tutors at
the university routinely refer to their students as "idiots" and
"imbeciles".
Furthermore, we have trustworthy reports on the enormous
amounts of money that young Bosnian graduates have to spend just to get their
foreign degrees and diplomas evaluated and recognized; is this how Universities
mean to encourage the return of young professionals?
The war devastated the universities. It also witnessed
instances of real heroism on the part of professors and tutors who continued to
teach in abominable - often life-threatening - circumstances. And since the end
of the war, Bosnia and Herzegovina's difficult economic condition has meant that
teaching conditions are often very basic and uninspiring. But this does not
excuse the use of teaching methods which were abandoned decades ago elsewhere on
the continent. For example, you don't need extensive exposure to teaching
practices abroad to know that non-participatory, lecture-based rote-learning
does not constitute a legitimate pedagogic method.
This conference is the right place to address these issues,
because Sarajevo University, which accounts for almost half of the 80,000
students in BiH, sets the trend for the national Higher Education system. This
afternoon we have together in one place representatives of the Federation
political authorities and representatives of the university administration and
teaching staff. Together you can chart a way forward. The university
representatives cannot put their ideas into practice without the help of the
politicians, and the politicians cannot take the correct initiatives without
guidance from the university.
The number of universities in Bosnia and Herzegovina has to be
reduced. This is not a matter exclusively for those present today. But it is a
matter which will have a defining impact on the success or failure of your own
reforms. The duplication of teaching courses offered by a fractured Higher
Education system represents a scandalous waste of scarce resources. Bosnia and
Herzegovina cannot afford seven universities. It doesn’t have the facilities,
the money, or the necessary numbers of qualified teaching staff.
Under the Dayton Peace Agreement, the funding of universities
in the Federation rests with the cantons. The role of my office is to ensure the
fair and efficient implementation of Dayton. There exist in the settlement
mechanisms whereby arrangements can be altered with the consent of all parties.
With good will and consensus it will be possible to change the legal mandate for
the provision of Higher Education and move this to the Entity level, where it
can be properly coordinated. Equally important, in view of the urgency of
reform, consensus can boost efficiency under the existing legal arrangement.
Nothing prevents the cantonal education ministries, for example, from working
together within a framework established and maintained by the Federation
Education Ministry.
In the six years since Dayton, the focus of the International
Community in Bosnia and Herzegovina has been on keeping the peace and
kick-starting the economy. There have been many commendable efforts by NGOs to
make a positive impact in the field of education, yet it may have been the case
that insufficient attention has been paid to this area, at least by the lead
agencies. It has become clear, though, that as long as the education sector
severely underperforms, this will threaten the economic and social future of BiH
and its prospects of European integration. We still have directors in the school
system who would rather deny pupils the use of computers than allow the
computers to be shared with children of a different community. We still see
textbooks in use which perpetuate vicious nonsense about ethnic separation. We
still see children obliged to travel many miles to school because of communal
considerations.
Is the situation hopeless?
No it isn't. Because in this country there are legions of
honest, hard-working, competent and principled educators. There are teachers
whose guiding light is the welfare of their students and the pursuit of
knowledge. And there are administrators too, who work long and hard to provide
these model teachers with the facilities and equipment they need. These are our
partners.
Bosnia and Herzegovina is now on the brink of breaking away
from its recent past and setting out on the road towards Europe, with a
functioning political system and an improving economy. Refugees are returning
home and a sense of normality is more and more apparent. Yet the challenges are
huge. The central social function of education is to give young people the
skills they need in order to meet challenges. Just as Bosnia and Herzegovina
faces particularly demanding challenges, its education system needs to be
particularly good.
And it can be. Creativity, originality, enquiry, and wit are
the stock in trade of Sarajevo's university culture. These qualities must be
harnessed in the cause of reforming the university and reforming the education
system across the country. There is no time to lose. Your students will not
forgive you if you fail.
